Be nice. Or else.
Orange County, CA Product Design at Weedmaps Joined over 4 years ago
You probably don't need a screener form anymore. You can run software in the background that can predict—to a reasonable degree—if you've actually read an article or not. It could watch things like time on page, scroll behaviors, etc. This is basically how Google's reCAPTCHA works. If it passes, show a share button. If not, don't.
This is probably tougher on desktop browsers where the user can just grab the URL and paste it anywhere they want.
They could sell the crap out of that data on their ad exchange. Surprised they aren't doing this already.
Amazon has some built-in protections against this type of behavior. Competitors used to do this same kind of brigading with reviews.
Coding doesn't irk me. I enjoy coding.
But I think designers are better positioned to impact a business, project, experience, etc in other areas. Specifically in understanding who the user is, what they're goals and scenarios are, aligning with business needs, collaborating on prototypes, and user testing.
The prototyping can be done in code. Some times it is required but mostly it isn't.
If it suits your work style—carry on. But I wonder if it should be a requirement for designers.
Heh. It's not easy. Our design system is very much an MVP. So when we add or update the system, it's a laborious process of updating sketch libs, documentation in Confluence, and React components.
Hey Kris. Coincidentally, I discovered the problem a few hours after I posted this. Turns out it was a third-party Sketch plugin that was messing me up. I removed it and now Craft sync works perfect!
Thanks for reaching out!
Gaining soft skills is hard. They are rarely taught explicitly in school or elsewhere. You or your employer can hire consultants to teach you how to do this well. There are also a lot of good books on the subject (Emotional Intelligence, Radical Candor, etc). Jared Spool has a lot of good writing and talks on this stuff.
The best way to learn is to practice.
The good news is because soft skills are so hard to acquire, if you've mastered them, you are extremely desirable in almost any company.
Critiques are about making the design better and they should be a regular part of the process.
They consist of a group of people who have a stake in the project's success and have the requisite knowledge in order to ask good questions. Critiques are about asking questions after all. Deep, thoughtful questions about the decisions that went into the design. If the reasoning behind the question can't be supported (by evidence or otherwise) then the designer can take note and reconsider the decision.
However, asking questions like these (especially about why they made certain decisions) is inherently antagonistic and people will become defensive. This is not good. So make sure you phrase questions about the work and not the designer. All feedback must come from a place of support and compassion. It takes practices to do this consistently but it is well worth it. For example, don't say, "Why did you design the flow like this?" Instead, say, "Talk about how this flow works well to achieve the desired outcome." Both of these questions get at the same point but one is about the person and the other about the work.
Overall, this kind of nonviolent communication is key to creating a psychologically safe space for people to work. When people feel safe, they will be more open to critique and more willing to contribute. Safety also lets people be more daring and courageous in their ideas which can lead to innovative designs.
To go back to my point point above about "low-quality work", the good DM would not go to the designer and tell her that the work isn't good. Instead the good DM would simply recognize that she needs help and facilitate activities that will get her back on track. Critique is a good tool for that, though not the only one.
Some things I think good design managers do:
Be nice. Or else.
Designer News is a large, global community of people working or interested in design and technology.