How is Invision Studio?

6 months ago from , Digital Design Nomad

It seems that the first batch of the invites are out. Just want to know how it is? Still waiting for my invite.

42 comments

  • Andrew CiobanasiuAndrew Ciobanasiu, 6 months ago

    But really

    Kidding aside, I'm curious to hear about performance and any news on Invision V7.

    14 points
  • Thomas Wilhelm, 6 months ago

    Most important question: can you underline text?

    11 points
    • Alex Hazel, 6 months ago

      Second most important question: Can you apply a border to one side of a shape without some silly workaround or hack. Just. Like. CSS.

      2 points
  • Mattan IngramMattan Ingram, 6 months ago

    Can anyone explain why they are so excited about Studio?

    There are two things it seems to do differently/better than Sketch:

    • Prototyping with relatively complex animations
    • It appears to have the 9-point reference tool that Adobe tools have

    But in terms of things I actually need?

    • Does it understand content flow at all? Can it resize a button or component based on length of text within? Can it wrap content based on screen size?

    • How does handling multiple designers work? Is there branching or versioning?

    It seems like the stuff I care about the most is touched on the least in all design tool marketing.

    10 points
    • Andrew C, 6 months ago

      I think we're in a bit of a golden era for design tool experimentation. It's nice to go from Adobe owning the market, to having a bunch of serious contenders come out of the web/sass market.

      Although, I've said this before here, you'll probably need to be 10x better than Sketch to pull me away from it at this point. They release features with a product focus that I REALLY dig. One of the biggest drawbacks of Studio to me is... InVision itself. Its product strategy has been so land-grabby that I'm not sure I could trust the company to expand the product in the focused way Sketch does. Basically, I trust Sketch to think about me more when releasing (release bugs aside).

      11 points
      • Cristian MoiseiCristian Moisei, 6 months ago

        Golden era? The two most popular tools at the moment are a 25 year old image editor (Photoshop) and a buggy illustration tool (Sketch). None of the other tools coming to the market do anything radically different, and if you think I'm wrong here, please name a few ways in which any of the new tools (including Sketch) completely change the way we design, make our lives easier and our work faster, improve the quality of our work or significantly raise the bar for what is possible.

        3 points
        • Andrew C, 6 months ago

          This post is overly reductionistic. We now have animation tools like Principal or Framer, prototyping tools like InVision or Marvel, developer interfacing tools like Zeplin.io. I can find free high-quality photography at Unsplash, or great icons to use at Noun Project or iconmonstr. And just straight up new design platforms like Figma (and now InVision Studio).

          Not only that, but the tools are getting VERY specific in to things we need. Sketch opened up Symbols with overrides in a way that was groundbreaking. There's a reason why every new design tools launches with this feature.

          Hardly the dichotomy of Photoshop or the buggy little illustration tool called Sketch you're making it out to be.

          21 points
          • Cristian MoiseiCristian Moisei, 6 months ago

            That is a fair argument, I was referring to the main design software, and didn’t consider the great tools we got to complement that.

            It doesn’t change the fact that our primary tools still suck, but you are right we can do a lot more now in terms of prototyping or handover and we have easy access to resources.

            1 point
        • Anthony Harmon, 6 months ago

          The most appealing thing about Studio from what I've gathered isn't a new feature set, bur rather a more comprehensive workflow within a single app. They went after the time is money "thing" which I think is a genius place to insert yourself in a highly competitive market space. All that being said...let's see if it actually delivers on it's promises :)

          0 points
      • John PJohn P, 6 months ago

        I think we're in a bit of a golden era for design tool experimentation

        Wouldn't go that far, golden age of rectangle drawing tools maybe.

        1 point
      • Rob GillRob Gill, 5 months ago

        The most sense I've ever read on DN, well said. And great follow up too. 100% agree with your statements.

        0 points
  • Bryan Mortensen, 6 months ago

    Based on my scour of twitter, I think they sent out exactly one invite today. And he posted no screenshots or impressions.

    4 points
  • Ashraf Hamdy, 6 months ago

    I have tried it very quickly so my opinion doesn't reflect all the aspects of the application. My first reaction to it was that it is different than any design tool I've used before. It layouts the objects as if you're writing HTML and CSS of your objects and styling them with flex parameters. Also, all the objects have margins and paddings, in addition to width and height of course, so again, you'll feel like your designing in CSS not in a free canvas like Sketch for example. It was mainly for mobile apps design too. And I didn't find a quick way to export the artboard to images, I think they mainly depend on sharing the design link instead of exporting it. Again, I've just tried it for like 15 mins so I didn't explore all the features, but the least I can say is that it's revolutionary and will change the way designers work in the future.

    EDIT ------

    It seems like there is a confusion between 2 products with the same name! I received an email invitation to try out https://studio.design/ and at first I thought this was InVision Studio, but now I think it's a whole different product, which is very weird to have 2 products announcements near the same time with exactly the same name

    4 points
    • Julian H, 6 months ago

      Revolutionary like webflow? ;)

      3 points
      • Ashraf Hamdy, 6 months ago

        I haven't tried Webflow yet, but I checked their website and they seem to share the same direction of designing with CSS

        1 point
        • Jonathan PattersonJonathan Patterson, 6 months ago

          Webflow is nice. I created my website in it. I don't use it as a design tool though—despite their marketing push touting "design in the browser." I still think it's easier to push pixels (or vectors, more accurately) around in a program like Sketch or Illustrator, then code it on Webflow.

          2 points
      • isaac feldman, 6 months ago

        webflow is god

        0 points
    • Mattan IngramMattan Ingram, 6 months ago

      It layouts the objects as if you're writing HTML and CSS of your objects and styling them with flex parameters. Also, all the objects have margins and paddings, in addition to width and height of course, so again, you'll feel like your designing in CSS not in a free canvas like Sketch for example.

      I will be very pleased if this turns out the way I hope.

      Webflow is great but not really a design tool so much as a website builder. If Invision can find a happy medium between the two I will give them a lot of props.

      4 points
  • Todd FTodd F, 6 months ago

    Hesitant to use an Invision product again, but constraint based layout output is the make or break feature for us. Anyone know?

    4 points
    • John JacksonJohn Jackson, 6 months ago

      Why?

      2 points
      • Todd FTodd F, 23 days ago

        Just saying that our developers are quite enthusiastic about constraint-based layouts rather than the old fashioned fixed stuff. The real solution for us has to support constraint-based code output.

        0 points
    • Josh Sanders, 6 months ago

      care to elaborate a bit more?

      0 points
      • Todd FTodd F, 23 days ago

        Sorry, just saying that our developers are quite enthusiastic about constraint-based layouts rather than the old fashioned fixed stuff. The real solution for us has to support constraint-based code output for it to be useful.

        0 points
  • Johannes Neumeier, 6 months ago

    With all the advertising they do I have been asking myself that same question. What strikes me is how Sketch became so popular exactly because they were open, iterated openly and listened to feedback while constantly developing the product. I would hope Invision does not aim for a "killer release", but embrace an equally involved approach.

    2 points
  • Jrtorrents Dorman , 6 months ago

    Could have sworn they promised early access by December 2017 and general availability by end of January 2018. My gues is, they’re still fixing bugs

    1 point
    • Zhaoli Jin, 6 months ago

      yeah, I remember that, too. it seems they removed that text from landing page.

      1 point
    • David ThornDavid Thorn, 6 months ago

      I think it was DSM was supposed to launch in December and then Studio was always early 2018. Me thinks both are pushed back.

      0 points
  • Diego White, 3 months ago

    I have been trying it for a few hours this morning and i have to say i am extremely disappointed.

    I understand it is an early access and therefore it is buggy by nature, but i find it very difficult to manage to do anything right. The symbols (components they call them) and over rides seem not to work at all.

    Overall it looks like a bad rip off of Sketch (which i am not a big fan of) diminished in features and lacking of many productivity tools we need in a professional environment. Far from the promised "most powerful design software" advertised in their excellent teaser website.

    I would not be so critic if Invision hadn't raised so much our expectations through tons of paid content on Medium and other social networks.

    Let's wait until they refine it then. At the end this is a completely free piece of software and any effort by any company with those ideas in mind must be appreciated.

    1 point
    • Alfred Salib, 3 months ago

      I agree. I was really surprised that it lacked the super basic features that I look for in a design tool. I think I'm partly to blame though, for expecting too much too early.

      My assumption is that they're almost entirely focused on implementing the advanced features that make Studio stand out (animations & responsiveness, which I must admit are amazing) but I really wish they would have spent more time on the basic stuff, making it generally quick/easy to use.

      Reasons I haven't completely switched over from Sketch yet:

      1. Keyboard shortcuts (can't edit them - I've grown too used to Sketch's and find it really hard to change to this super weird one that is different still from Photoshop. Why can't these tools just stick with what works!?

      2. Components are a mess (although maybe I just don't understand how to use them properly. I had no issues with how Sketch symbols worked though)

      With that said, it's still early access. I'll reserve judgement until it is officially 'released'

      0 points
  • Josh Sanders, 6 months ago

    still waiting for my early access code as well... EXTREMELY excited to get my hands on studio!

    1 point
  • Alex HoffmanAlex Hoffman, 6 months ago

    I have a feeling part of getting the first release of early access is being quiet about it..

    1 point
  • Danny Lewandowski, 6 months ago

    I'm very interested and hope to try it out soon. Fingers crossed that it's all it's hyped up to be.

    This is probably a question for another thread, but besides Sketch and InVision Studio, what's the best desktop-based, cross-platform design/UX/UI/whatever-you-wanna-call-it tool? I've been looking for a solution that has responsive layouts, vector-based and good sharing/collaboration tools for a global team that run Windows and Mac. The ones I've looked at are:

    • Adobe XD (some good features like Repeat Grid, but that's about it)
    • Gravit (good features and FREE)
    • Affinity Designer (good features but no collaboration)
    • Adobe Illustrator (not really a UX-type app)

    I know other like Figma, Framer, etc are great but we are limited and not able to do any subscription based tools, unfortunately.

    Thanks for any input andsuggestions!

    0 points
  • Andrei Kreitor, 4 months ago

    I've subscribed for that 'early access' in October 2017 and it's pretty disappointing to wait up to this day..

    0 points
    • Jan Semler, 4 months ago

      Look up on twitter designers are rumbling about that, this is really bad communication from invision. They should have done the early access when the product is ready and not when it is in development. They made so much noise at the expense of the actual user.

      0 points
  • Dan OC, 6 months ago

    I heard the Enterprise tool costs 60k euros per year... pretty crazy.

    0 points
  • Cody IddingsCody Iddings, 6 months ago

    I'm excited to try it but waiting to see if it's actually better -- as in—does it enable me to truly work faster and more efficient?

    0 points