80

Taking Criticism

2 years ago from , Design at InVision, Writer at The Design Team, Mentor at Sketch Together

Taking criticism

Still struggling to be more like the chill naked dude on the right.

18 comments

  • Scott ThomasScott Thomas, 2 years ago

    I'm not going to lie... as a young designer I was more like

    Why Don't You Like Me

    28 points
  • Jonathan ShariatJonathan Shariat, 2 years ago

    The second one also helps because people will be too distracted to find the flaws in your work. haha

    Great comic Pablo, it says so much. We start by defending our work but we don't realize we were making it about defending our egos. Then you learn its not about you, its about doing good work. You learn to to welcome any criticism and be open about your flaws because thats what helps you grow and do good work.

    10 points
  • Edgar Chaparro, 2 years ago

    soo good hahaha

    5 points
  • Dan WilkinsonDan Wilkinson, 2 years ago

    One is the Knight class, and one the Deprived class from Dark Souls

    5 points
  • Jon MyersJon Myers, 2 years ago

    Amazing - lol

    Reminds me of this -

    20 Years Ago, Steve Jobs Demonstrated the Perfect Way to Respond to an Insult https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/20-years-ago-steve-jobs-demonstrated-the-perfect-w.html

    4 points
  • Daniel WearneDaniel Wearne, 2 years ago

    Still the hardest part of the job, not so much taking it, but learning how to hear the constructive gems, and which feedback to respond to.

    I find it has a lot to do with the relationship, and trust.

    2 points
    • Aaron MoodieAaron Moodie, 2 years ago

      Agree. Leaning how to give good feedback is also a big part of it. Feedback, when given well, is really inspirational.

      0 points
  • Account deleted 2 years ago

    When you start your career in a backward country then your employers break your spirit very fast (because they are scum). I remember myself in i.e. college, very proud of my work. If somebody said something bad about it, I perceived it as a personal insult. Nowadays, I am totally character on the right.

    2 points
  • Nice ShoesNice Shoes, 2 years ago

    Surely there's a in-between?

    Yeah, take feedback with a calm manner - but fight for you beliefs. Don't just roll over. If you appear to calm you may be perceived as a push-over, or worse; somebody that doesn't care.

    I'm seasoned - some might say very seasoned - but I've never lost my edge to fight for what I believe in.

    1 point
  • Bevan StephensBevan Stephens, 2 years ago

    Brilliant!

    1 point
  • Mike AbbotMike Abbot, 2 years ago

    It's really simple -> If you have a valid reason why something should look or work a certain way and you can prove it you should stick to your choice. Then your job is to convince others that your decision is the right one. That includes showing them all the other choices and explain why they won't work. You need a lot of experience and knowledge to be able to do this.

    If you are just sticking to your opinion because you personally like it, that means even you're not sure that it'll work. Then you shouldn't stick to it.

    Bam!

    1 point
  • Cristian Dragos, 2 years ago

    True Pablo... true... Even though I'm not getting naked when reading feedback email, I'm definitely closing my eyes :P

    1 point
  • Ignacio CorreiaIgnacio Correia, 2 years ago

    I am in between :)

    1 point
  • Edison CheeEdison Chee, 2 years ago

    Love the illustration!

    The confusing part comes when clients flip-flop between decisions. On some days, they seem to understand UX. On others, the simplest things (to me) seem to fly past their heads completely.

    Then I realised why: sometimes they choose not to see, because it takes too much effort to change the way they work/business processes to support a digital service.

    Looking back, the fact that I got them to flip-flop was a win. Otherwise, they would have done things the same old way and change nothing about it.

    0 points