74 comments

  • Abhijeet WankhadeAbhijeet Wankhade, over 3 years ago

    I prefer Comet over Experience Design CC

    31 points
  • Andrew SmithAndrew Smith, over 3 years ago

    Todays top questions

    • How do you insert an image
    • Why can't you align a repeated grid
    • Where are all the tools in this minimalistic wetdream

    image

    22 points
  • Ollie BarkerOllie Barker, over 3 years ago

    I get it's still an early preview, but how has it got this far without a proper colour picker or layers panel? Seriously if there's a reason tell me :)

    14 points
  • Daniel AdamsDaniel Adams, over 3 years ago

    Even though I haven't unveiled the full potential of it yet, my first impression was that Sketch and InVision had an accident an this is the result.

    13 points
  • Harish KumarHarish Kumar, over 3 years ago

    looks like its just a beta version.. its no-where near sketch (just my opinion) pls do not start an argument..

    11 points
  • Stuart McCoyStuart McCoy, over 3 years ago

    Because it has not been said enough yet, THIS IS A PREVIEW RELEASE. This means it's an early beat and is missing functionality. On purpose. Because it's still in development. It does show a lot of promise and will open the field of UI/UX design to people who don't cream their pants every time an article about Sketch is posted to DN.

    9 points
  • Vineeth GopalVineeth Gopal, over 3 years ago

    54 Mb for demo file. Slow clap.

    8 points
  • Vasil EnchevVasil Enchev, over 3 years ago

    Lamest name ever...

    7 points
  • Bjarke DaugaardBjarke Daugaard, over 3 years ago

    It's not a version 1.0 yet. Just an early preview

    7 points
  • Bruno BarrosBruno Barros, over 3 years ago

    What? Why is it unavailable via Adobe Creative Cloud desktop app?

    Downloading it outside of the regular CC download process is just silly.

    5 points
    • Abhijeet WankhadeAbhijeet Wankhade, over 3 years ago

      I am not even able to download it. It constantly keeps me taking to the CC app and does nothing.

      1 point
    • Florian GrauFlorian Grau, over 3 years ago

      I can now download it via Creative Cloud - let's see how it goes…

      2 points
    • Simon CarrascoSimon Carrasco, over 3 years ago

      same here — in France. It's just not on the CC app list... :(

      2 points
      • Paul NevinPaul Nevin, over 3 years ago

        Strange, it's been available for me (in France) since early this morning.

        1 point
      • Mike ChambersMike Chambers, over 3 years ago

        The initial preview is Mac and English. I am guessing you are not seeing it in the CC app because your language is set to French?

        If you go into the CC App settings, and set your language to English (may need to restart CC app), does XD then show up?

        More language support is on its way, and we are working on windows support.

        3 points
  • Bent StamnesBent Stamnes, over 3 years ago

    Gave it a go and there's definite potential here. Very crude so far, but potential for sure. As for the name, Comet always felt like it had too much peresonality for an Adobe product so it was bound to change, but "Adobe Experience Design CC" ..? Jeez. :)

    5 points
    • Michael G., over 3 years ago

      Completely agree. I was in the beta test group, and came away with the following thoughts on the kind of workflow I hope this brings:

      Photoshop and Illustrator: - Create mockups on artboards, with assets saved as smart objects and CC library items. - Export all of this to XD

      Experience Designer: - Work with imported artboards, shared assets, etc. - Refine designs, build prototypes and preview them.

      Design sync between applications: - Designs created in Ps and Ai should be able to be updated if edited in Xd. For example, let's say a UX architect has created low-fidelity designs in Xd to show basic interactivity. A visual designer should be able to take that document into Ps or Ai, and pick up right where the UXA left it - replacing low-fidelity imagery with high-fidelity imagery meant to be final design. Then, as that syncs with Xd, the prototype should update to reflect updated designs.

      If they can do this, that's where this becomes a very powerful workflow. For large teams on CC who are not going to just up and switch everyone to Sketch / Invision, this could be fantastic.

      1 point
  • Harper Lieblich, over 3 years ago

    I spent a few minutes playing with Xd this morning. Here's my initial impression.

    • This app is fast! Fast and buttery smooth. Not sure how well it'll handle highly complex files, but I have a good feeling.
    • The spartan interface is a welcome change from Adobe's usual fare.
    • It's definitely not done yet. There's all sorts of functionality I hope they add before the production release.
    • Being able to prototype right from my design files is awesome!

    Can't wait to see what they do with it. In the meantime my daily driver will still be Sketch though.

    5 points
  • Falko JosephFalko Joseph, over 3 years ago

    It is pretty fast, and seems quite stable (performance-wise) so there's that. The missing features is just a matter of time. I'm quite confident it will be good :)

    4 points
  • Mike AbbotMike Abbot, over 3 years ago

    This is nowhere near Sketch...hopefully this is a really early preview....

    4 points
  • Emanuel SerbanoiuEmanuel Serbanoiu, over 3 years ago

    Are there rulers somewhere? I can't find them!

    4 points
  • Dom BriggsDom Briggs, over 3 years ago

    I'm liking it so far and I haven't found I've missed the layers panel yet. All the Sketch keyboard short cuts are working, so I can still group objects and ungroup. Having said that I haven't built anything complex yet. The repeat grid thing is pretty slick and the prototyping feature is convenient. I'm quite interested in this longer term!

    3 points
    • Matthew O'ConnorMatthew O'Connor, over 3 years ago

      Really? I can get no good shortcuts to work (grouping/ungrouping not including... as they should be standard in most tools like this). I was annoyed I could not change the size of a shape from my keyboard, or quickly just to the shapes options like in sketch (alt+shift).

      0 points
  • Adam Hayman, over 3 years ago (edited over 3 years ago )

    Played around with it a bit. Definitely seems like the product of Sketch and Invision having a night of drinking and debauchery.

    Some things it still needs: Layers, Rulers, Color Picker, Zoom Tool, Guides, More control over the Repeat Grid, Image insertion

    3 points
  • Patrick LoonstraPatrick Loonstra, over 3 years ago

    Not bad, not bad. Like the fact that you can do basic prototyping in it also.

    3 points
  • Hakim Mazouz, over 3 years ago

    So is this supposed to be like Sketch but with the added ability of being able to prototype and "hand it off" to a device to view it on there?

    3 points
  • Rolando MurilloRolando Murillo, over 3 years ago

    Adobe XDDDDD.

    3 points
  • Jason EtcovitchJason Etcovitch, over 3 years ago

    Sketch was the only Mac-only thing that I really cared about, and now this too :( (I'm on a PC)

    3 points
  • Cristian MoiseiCristian Moisei, over 3 years ago

    It might take several years before this becomes a serious tool, but considering the direction it is taking, it already feels better than Sketch (consider the way you start a project in Sketch New Document > Tools > Artboard > select from a dull list of templates, with the way you do it in Comet where you just pick what you want from that awesome start screen).

    3 points
  • Spencer HoltawaySpencer Holtaway, over 3 years ago

    Potentially huge workflow changer for people working on Adobe CC and we're talking about what they decided to name it.

    3 points
  • Chris DelbuckChris Delbuck, over 3 years ago

    I appreciate the effort Adobe has put into the project to address the evolving needs of interface designers, albeit quite late. This is a radical step for Adobe for sure. Not utilizing the existing cross-platform frameworks and conventions from existing CC apps is a huge departure.

    It's buttery smooth, granted there isn't much there yet. If it weren't I'd say that Adobe should abort the project. It's hard to make judgments about it yet because so many core features aren't there. While it's easy to imagine what Gradient Fills or Symbols might do, it takes a little more work to imagine how they'll be implemented into the framework there.

    I'm a little puzzled by how light this preview release is. The videos last year that came out showing off Comet seemed as if they were way further ahead than this. What's the deal Adobe? When will a real feature filled version be shared?

    3 points
  • Jamie FangJamie Fang, over 3 years ago (edited over 3 years ago )

    I'm lovin' it. shrug

    2 points
  • Kushtrim XhaferiKushtrim Xhaferi, over 3 years ago

    Comet is a very nice, smooth working tool, BUT as i sad about 147853quadrillion times, it needs LAYERS... and RULERS... and a COLORPICKER... GRIDS... and so one. I can't understand how the assumed we wouldn't need these functions. holy banana.

    i do not want to use 15 different apps to get the design done. so i still use sketch (though it has so many little dirty damn bugs).

    i hope the app grows quickly. we'll see what happens. .

    2 points
  • Norm Sheeran, over 3 years ago

    Let battle commence.

    2 points
  • Marc Nothrop, over 3 years ago

    They're trying to simplify as much as possible, and find new(ish!) ways to do things, like the Repeat Grid, and auto-text styles.

    I hope they're able to resist the clamour for traditional 'must haves' like Layers – and the 'busy work' they often cause. It'll be a hard balancing act, but if they can avoid too much baggage this could be a very lightweight, highly productive app.

    2 points
    • Duncan RussellDuncan Russell, over 3 years ago

      Yeah, I'm totally on board with "let's not spend half our time naming and organising layers" – but I still need to be able to lock, group and reorder objects at the very least.

      2 points
      • Peter Flynn, over 3 years ago

        You can do all those things already:

        • Cmd-L to lock/unlock an object. If you click or marquee over a locked object, you get a little handle that lets you unlock it.
        • Cmd-G to group, Cmd-Shift-G to ungroup. Double-click to drill down into a group, or Cmd-click to direct select inside a group (or deeper subgroup).
        • Object > Arrange to change z-order.

        Thought I should mention that in case you're not aware it's possible. OTOH, if you were already aware and your point is it feels more efficient to do these sorts of things via a traditional layers panel, I totally get where you're coming form. We definitely want to strike the best possible balance of lightweight and productive.

        0 points
  • Eike ThiesEike Thies, over 3 years ago (edited over 3 years ago )

    only for mac?! I mean come on, you were supposed to be an alternative for slack for us windows users (i know it will evidently be available for pc, but just dissapointed that it isn't for now)

    1 point
  • Andrei ScarlatescuAndrei Scarlatescu, over 3 years ago

    Just tried it, it seems like the 'Zoom' tool is missing. I could really use that :-) Looking forward into the updates, there's a lot of potential here.

    1 point
  • scott parsons, over 3 years ago

    I know this is just a preview, but is the "prototyping" just screen to screen clickthroughs? So far this is a nice piece of software, but nothing going on to make me switch to it. Let us see what the next version is like!

    1 point
  • Cody Gallner, over 3 years ago

    Downloading it. Just not quite like the pink icon.

    1 point
  • Kris KimKris Kim, over 3 years ago

    no hover state..... again :( Can anything possibly make desktop app prototype without hover state?

    1 point
  • Fri RasyidiFri Rasyidi, over 3 years ago

    Dude, you're not supposed to share this news yet.

    1 point
  • Nathan NNathan N, over 3 years ago

    Shame there's no PC version yet.

    1 point
  • Demian Borba, over 3 years ago

    Hi guys,

    Thanks for all the feedback here.

    Would you mind adding these feature requests to Adobe XD UserVoice ? That way you could be informed when the features land.

    It's important to highlight that this first Public Preview is a solid foundation for new features to arrive with our monthly releases moving forward. This is just the beginning of a long and fun journey.

    We will be answering more questions tomorrow here on Designer News. Feel free to send your question there as well.

    Thanks for helping us shape the future of Adobe XD.

    Demian Borba | Product Manager, UX Design | @demianborba issue in the survey.

    0 points