13 comments

  • Jake Lazaroff, 4 years ago

    There are a million different cross-disciplinary things that can benefit designers. Maybe they should study whatever they want.

    37 points
    • Bradley Ryan, 4 years ago

      Right on. Why phrase it as if they're mutually exclusive?

      Everyday I collaborate with data scientists, analysts, and researchers that help me understand the business impact and ramifications of my designs ... And I build hi-fi prototypes through code.

      Use whatever cross-disciplinary learnings that help you achieve your best designs.

      2 points
      • Andy MerskinAndy Merskin, 4 years ago (edited 4 years ago )

        Completely agree. We have the same format at Markit on Demand. Our designers are sharp as a whip, and a few of us do enjoy coding both prototypes and production-grade code in certain instances.

        I think as the disciplines of design and development keep evolving (and they will), separating concerns and roles makes our teams way more efficient and gives us opportunities to finesse the particular areas we're focused on, like prototyping.

        For those who are more business-savvy, let them be, and let them focus on that within their teams so they can influence the wireframers, visual designers, and prototypers/developers to make sure the product is exactly what the client asked for, not some cobbled together mess made by one person who's weaker in every area.

        0 points
  • Vlad Danilov, 4 years ago

    Designer Evolution

    7 points
  • Dirk HCM van BoxtelDirk HCM van Boxtel, 4 years ago

    OH FOR FUCKS SAKE.

    4 points
  • Mike Wilson, 4 years ago

    Yes. Yes. Yes.

    3 points
  • Jon MyersJon Myers, 4 years ago

    I agree with the overall premise of the article, but it’s written too simplistically to be useful or actionable.

    Good designers have always been synthesizers of multiple disciplines and domains to create products that best address the problems and situations at hand. AKA - Design thinking.

    With the rise of the “Product Designer” - the need for multi-disciplinary approaches is coming more to the forefront.

    It would have been better to focus on the article on more specific aspects of business and help designers understand how those aspects are directly connected to what they're creating.

    0 points
  • Sam Lester, 4 years ago (edited 4 years ago )

    This title is pretty misleading. Code literacy and business skills aren't mutually exclusive.

    0 points
  • Lee Mahayati, 4 years ago

    true.. because designer always have the idea.. and sometimes the idea could be change to something valuable or secret sauce of product.. that's why better learn business rather than code..

    0 points
  • David MDavid M, 4 years ago (edited 4 years ago )

    This is easily one of the most important topics in Design right now that often is swept under the rug bc designers' eyes tend to glaze over anything remotely related to the word "business."

    Understandable, as a lot of us do have backgrounds in fine art, visual design, marketing, etc and sometimes the ENTIRE REASON we got into this game was to simply do stuff we loved and not stuff we don't. We hear we need to code, need to go to more conferences, be more active on social media, need to blog more, more succulent plants on the desk, etc and this EASILY could tire anyone out. I understand completely, trust me. BUT (of course there's a "but") this notion of expanding our perspectives about what design is to include business goals/performance/strategy/etc is a critical one that WILL make you better at your craft in the same way that designing for systems instead of pages made you better at your craft, in the same way of mapping your designs to actual user research made you better at your craft, in the same way that taking the leap from print to digital made you better at your craft and so on and so on.

    So do it. Take the dive. And relax, the waters fine. ;)

    0 points
  • Theodora NastaTheodora Nasta, 4 years ago

    For UX/UI designers is for sure more important to understand the business side of what they're designing than coding, but many design degree programs these days start combining all of those 3. The problem is that for small design companies is better to have someone who can design & code for financial reasons, even if the application of their design won't be of such value for the business.

    0 points
  • Terry OTerry O, 4 years ago

    I love how the guy who wrote this worked at Evernote, a product that has repeatedly gone to shit thanks to terrible design decisions. Huh.

    0 points
  • barry saundersbarry saunders, 4 years ago

    There's no one unified body of knowledge for designers. Business is a useful field to understand, so is code, so is UX or user testing or business analysis or conversion optimisation or communication theory or finance or ergonomics or accessibility or advertising or any number of related fields. Ultimately you'll have value no matter what you study, but you'll find your career direction will be shaped by what you specialise in. If you like strategy, entrepreneurialism, startups, then by all means study business. If you like working with devs, then study code or business analysis. Consulting, UX/user testing.

    Ultimately, if you approach design with a humble attitude and learn from engaging with people, you learn what you need to know.

    0 points