• Ian GoodeIan Goode, over 7 years ago

    Ok, harsh but fair criticism:

    50% off nothing is nothing. What is Division bringing to the table? What's the driving idea behind it? What's the mission? If you want people on board you need to sell them something.

    11 points
    • tony wtony w, over 7 years ago

      Agree. I find it hard to get excited due to the lack of... well, nothing :) is there any screenshots or something that you could put up?

      1 point
    • Rolando Murillo, over 7 years ago (edited over 7 years ago )

      I don’t find this harsh. Without giving much detail, quite a few people have already subscribed and expressed interest. I was hoping to answer questions here anyway.

      What’s the driving idea behind it?

      From the many design tools I’ve tried, they all compose a visual mockup but not a real structure as the implementation would do. I wouldn’t have a problem with this if it didn’t affect my design process. These tools are dumb! They are not aware of the content that you put in. If you add text to a container, it should make it grow, it should scroll if there’s a height limit. If you want to have an image on the background of your container, you shouldn’t need to create a mask, etc.

      What’s the mission?

      From what I said above, it disappoints me that this is the same state we are replicating and bringing to touch screens. With the advent of powerful touch devices like the iPad Pro, we should really seize the touch capabilities and make it practical to design complex interfaces.

      3 points
      • Hanu ManHanu Man, over 7 years ago

        Pues si... estoy totalmente de acuerdo en que es el momento indicado para sacarle partido tanto a la potencia como de lo táctil del iPad Pro. Sin embargo no es tarea sencilla e incluso entiendo porque a gigantes como Adobe le está costando tanto dar el siguiente paso.

        La clave es crear una herramienta que cuente con las mismas propiedades del medio donde va ser aplicada. Eso es todo.

        Siempre tengo en mente la idea de una herramiente de diseño "perfecta" y eso me ha llevado a desarrollar una que otra idea curiosa, así que si en algo puedo ayudar... gustoso de compartir puntos de vista.

        1 point
      • Michael CookMichael Cook, over 7 years ago

        Have you tried out Antetype? It's approaching design with a more structural, responsive system but I would love for it to have some competitors.

        If you have tried it, I would love to hear about the planned/anticipated differentiators.

        1 point
    • diego fernandezdiego fernandez, over 7 years ago

      Fair yet, a detail that is worth highlighting is the one-liner:

      Research for the modern design tool has begun.

      The word research by itself makes me optimistic because it means Division is not only looking for validation but also giving its target audience to evolve the idea from the get-go.

      1 point