Show DN: Skype for Mac Concept(

over 6 years ago from Roland Hidvegi, Product Designer

  • Joel CalifaJoel Califa, over 6 years ago

    Really? I always think it's more impressive when an entire team that has to deal with reality, constraints, budgets, deadlines, and limited resources does a better job than a single person with none of that.

    33 points
    • Roland Hidvegi, over 6 years ago

      The Microsoft team knows everything about their users, I know just my own needs, so they could do a much better job. This is a quick concept that can open new opportunities.

      14 points
      • Shaun Webberly, over 6 years ago

        This is the type of attitude that we should all take when approaching unsolicited UI redesigns. It's just a single person's POV, sans any data or design requirements that the Microsoft team may have. Not an indictment of their work, but rather a more aesthetic form of exploration. Nice job.

        10 points
      • Evan KnightEvan Knight, over 6 years ago


        0 points
    • Joe Blau, over 6 years ago

      While I generally agree, I've been on some teams with uninformed and politically motivated people in leadership positions. I've literally seen team leaders make terrible product decisions due to not understanding their reality, constraints, budgets, deadlines and limited resources. Just because you have the information; that doesn't mean you make better product design decisions.

      5 points