iOS Music Concept(

almost 7 years ago from Niels Mulder, Visual Designer at UNITiD

  • Moeed MohammadMoeed Mohammad, almost 7 years ago

    The conception bit looks cool but the execution is really poor. A few points:

    1. "Chrome accent unnecessary" You can't just claim things as unnecessary. There are probably very good reasons as to why there is a volume slider there. What if your hardware buttons aren't working? If you're referring to the actual chrome texture—well that's subjective. It's part of the look and feel of the app and there is nothing wrong with it.

    2. "Orange highlights don't match blue with blue pallet in Cover Flow" Again—you're taking this far too seriously. There is nowhere that says you can only use one color. Nowhere. The orange works well on the main screen because it has good contrast with the generally dark UI. Which means it'll always be visible no matter what's in the background.

    3. Album art not centered Look, this is just pure designer pleasing nonsense. I'm sure nobody who buys an iPhone checks to see if the album art is centered. There's nothing wrong with focusing on minor details, because they do make the overall product better, but you have to make sure you're spending time on the right things.

    4. Small touch targets This just seems like speculation, or something that happens to you. If there was actually an issue with a large enough user-base, it wouldn't take Apple a long time to release a fix. This is a non issue.

    5. Bottom nav takes up useful space This isn't an issue at all. Most iOS apps are generally within the same height range for the tabbar. It's just your opinion that it takes up too much space. There is nothing wrong with that, unless you're forcing people to agree with your opinion.

    6. It still feels like the same Music app When you have a product that is used by millions of people around the world, you have to be cautious with every feature decision you make. Look at the botched state of Windows 8. Great—they pioneered 'Flat Design' but at the expense of alienating their users. A lot of them. I'm sure every single designed at Apple wants to redesign the Music app but you can't do an overnight design mid-release cycle and expect everything to be okay. Everything has a cost.

    Your Prototype: 1. Almost nobody uses the landscape feature in Music. It's cool to look at and show off, but it's essentially unusable. You're whole concept is based on the idea that people use albums to play music. Sometimes that's true, but mostly people will look at the song list and jump to a specific song. 9 times out of 10.

    1. In a perfect world where everyone bought music, everyone would have album art and everything would look pretty. That's just not the case. People download music even if they buy music regularly. Downloaded music usually has no embedded album art and generally shitty meta-data.

    2. The progress bar in your design is too thin to be usable.

    3. Using a hamburger icon for a) unnecessary b) a cop-out c) looks the same as the move indicator (in the up next popover). The way the tab-bar is laid out in the current Music app is perfect. You have the main sections, and a more tab where you can customize your tab-bar. Everybody has different preferences. For some people, Playlists are more important than Albums, and they can easily change it.

    4. Apart from a few buttons, you're using flat colors in the app. Not only does this look pretty ugly, it also does not match the rest of the design language in iOS.

    5. Your design doesn't account for iTunes Match / iCloud.

    6. The Play/Next/Prev buttons are way too big. I think at the risk of creating a touch target too small, you've created one too large, which would likely have the same negative effect (You'll touch something you don't want to).

    7. On the whole 'Flat Design' thing Stop following trends. Everything you're doing now is going to be outdated very very soon. It's only a matter of time. Flat design, apart from being a made up term, is terribly unrealistic in any practical application. It only works for whitespace heavy, type heavy, simple websites. Trying to cram 'Flat design' into a user interface is a recipe for disaster.

    5 points