13 comments

  • Adam T.Adam T., 5 years ago (edited 5 years ago )

    Perhaps part of the problem behind the shutdown (just my assumption here) is that nobody knew at all what they did. I don't mean this badly, but they were always just that recognizable logo and their landing page that kept popping up on Dribbble or on DN. I was never sure if it was an agency, or an app to find co-founders, or to collorate on ideation... I mean that as no slight, it's clear to many people that wasn't the case, and I always appreciated the lightweight and refined design styles.

    8 points
    • Duncan RussellDuncan Russell, 5 years ago

      I was never sure if it was an agency, or an app to find co-founders, or to collorate on ideation...

      ^ This. I have no idea what it actually was.

      1 point
  • Milosz FalinskiMilosz Falinski, 5 years ago

    As someone who open sourced a side-project on Assembly last year (Octobox), this is sad news, but not too surprising. Initial response for Octobox was great, but as soon as that first wave of interest died down, there was just complete silence. It's the main reason project is offline now, as I didn't have the capacity to work on it myself, or interest to turn it into yet another boastful startup.

    It's a very powerful idea for a website/community, but, ironically, it suffered from problems exactly opposite to those faced by open source projects. It was over-designed and not active enough. I wish the team focused on contributing more to projects, and finding contributors, instead of redesigning the portal over and over.

    2 points
  • Kevin Brennan, 5 years ago

    The sentence seems a bit misleading. They're saying products made by Assembly were used by 4 million people not that Assembly had 4 million users. Or am I reading that incorrectly?

    2 points
    • Ed AdamsEd Adams, 5 years ago

      More than 4 million people used products built by the Assembly Community

      You have it exactly right, there is a cumulative total of 4 million people using Assembly services.

      3 points
    • Rick KhannaRick Khanna, 5 years ago

      Yep. If they had 4 million users they would not be shutting down.

      1 point
      • Luca Candela, 5 years ago

        It's completely possible. The question is, how many of those active? And another question would be how many of them willing to pay for the service. See, it's actually pretty hard to get VC funding just on # of users alone nowadays, unless you're a complete runaway success you need to have some kind of monetization plan.

        0 points
  • Maggie AppletonMaggie Appleton, 5 years ago

    Super disappointed about this one - Assembly was great for the 7+ months I was part of the community. Built some cool stuff, met plenty of great people, huge catalyst to produce new portfolio work and try out product ideas. Led to plenty of personal and career development for me.

    But then they transitioned to being "changelog" which I think was a pivot to try and salvage the company. Not surprised to read this after seeing it lose steam over the last few months.

    Still, kudos to the whole Assembly team. Really was an amazing idea. Wish it could have worked.

    1 point
  • Paul MorelPaul Morel, 5 years ago

    Didn't Assembly recently change directions from being a type of open-source collaborative platform to change logs with comments?

    Is it possible radical change contributed to its demise? Or am I misunderstanding the situation?

    1 point
    • Ed AdamsEd Adams, 5 years ago

      Maybe the radical change was a "last stand" effort to keep themselves from going under.

      0 points
  • Mark GillilandMark Gilliland, 5 years ago

    Disappointed, but saw this coming. Worked on a few Assembly-based projects, and while the people involved were generally great, it was hard to keep track of what was happening within a project and keep things organised. All of the projects (5 or 6) just fizzled out.

    0 points
  • Matthew CriderMatthew Crider, 5 years ago

    Was hoping to see something happen out of the Buckets CMS but should've feared the worst considering there's been no progress for 6 months.

    0 points
  • Ed AdamsEd Adams, 5 years ago

    It seemed to me like Assembly was a not-as-good GitHub clone that let you open bounties on issues to incentivize them. I dunno if I'm surprised, you'd need to do a lot to beat GitHub.

    0 points