48

"We're going to improve DN" *crickets*

9 months ago from , Front End, DevOps, Graphic Design, System Architecture, Social Media, Fabrication, Mechanical Engineering

Just wanted to sit back and appreciate the most highly upboated Message of the Day DN has seen.

  • Crickets

23 comments

  • dh .dh ., 9 months ago

    Still questioning why i'm going to this site, think it's just a habit. Make DN great again!

    19 points
  • Alex HoffmanAlex Hoffman, 9 months ago

    The website itself is just fine. The problem is that it's been bombarded with self-promoters and spammers who most likely use several accounts to boost their posts to the top. Don't get me wrong, there's nothing wrong with self-promotion. But when people post their ecommerce agency's website for shameless self-promotion, that's when it becomes spam.

    They tried to solve for that but introducing a downvote button, but the haters and trolls ruined that.

    I'd like to see what ideas the community has other than complaining and hitting the upvote button to give themselves a virtual pat on the back.

    18 points
    • Ken Em, 9 months ago

      The community has given their ideas in previous topics on this. DN isn't going to change until they decide they want to change. As it is now, they seem perfectly fine with the site being a spam dumping ground.

      3 points
    • Catalin CimpanuCatalin Cimpanu, 9 months ago

      Correct. About 90% of the bans I dish out are for blatant self-promoters, low-quality (listicle) submitters, and voting rings rather than actual off-topic spam.

      0 points
  • Dan GDan G, 9 months ago

    bows

    7 points
  • Ken Em, 9 months ago

    "Upboated"

    As for DN actually improving anything ... LOL

    5 points
  • Andrew McWattersAndrew McWatters, 9 months ago

    I'm stumbling in here from Hacker News via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21812442 which was posted supposedly 3 hours ago at the time of me posting here, but I swear I saw it pop up yesterday.

    A few observations from my point of view relating to myself viewing DN less, while my reading of HN continued:

    • The move from news.layervault.com to designernews.co was symbolic to me in that a new era of ownership began. I have no judgements about the ownership of the site, but the simple change of the URL was, yes, jarring to me. Small things matter.

    • Notable members of the design community either left (Visual Idiot, et al.) or stopped posting quality content. It's been enough years that I've even forgotten a few giants' names, but would recognize them if I saw them again.

    • My velocity in design work for several years, after 2015 up to now, dropped. I peaked in output after becoming a member of Awwwards and getting featured in a few places, and I'm trying to get myself off the ground again. Has the same thing happened to many other designers since then?

    Do we rely heavily on each other and the zeitgeist of the design world? Not much has changed in the last few years, I've noticed. Maybe I'm out of touch. I would bet heavily on this.

    5 points
    • Chris KeithChris Keith, 9 months ago

      Good context! I totally forgot about layervault. Seems like so long ago.

      I keep wandering back here because of how bad I want it to be good. There’s always design Twitter I guess.

      1 point
  • Brennan Smith, 9 months ago

    DN jumped the shark when they took away the invite system and monetized the site.

    4 points
  • Jim SilvermanJim Silverman, 9 months ago

    "crickets" speaks volumes. this site was left to rot.

    3 points
    • Michael KellyMichael Kelly, 9 months ago

      This thread is almost a week old, and not a single DN community manager has chimed in.

      Do they even have one anymore????

      0 points
  • Cihad TurhanCihad Turhan, 9 months ago

    I used to be a very active member of this community. Just checked my profile and saw "over 6 years ago". Probably I'm the oldest member in this thread. Back then, community grew just by referrals so that made quality to be stable and under-control. It was small community, maybe 100-200 members, but it was sincere. It was like a small town, everyone knows each other.

    They inevitably removed invites because it was growing slowly. We saw many spams after that. Some people posted backlinks to make their SEO "better". These are all normal when a product is open to public but the thing is, this product used to have a different url news.layervault.com. People from layervault was quite proactive and made important improvements. Also, the old url reminds me news.ycombinator.com. It's like a twin sister of it so I liked the old one better.

    I still visit almost everyday this site. Needless to say, I couldn't find the old spirit. I think it all happened when layervault said goodbye.

    3 points
  • Robert AniteiRobert Anitei, 9 months ago

    Make DN Great Again!

    2 points
  • Aaron MoodyAaron Moody, 9 months ago

    Reminds me of great design forums back in the day (who remembers talk freelance?)

    Loyal posters eventually stop posting for one reason or another, and the users who just like to read (like me) don't step in and post, instead we wait for others to do the posting and create the discussions.

    DN will get great again, when people start posting what they want to talk about The site isn't broken, we're just lazy & or busy actually working.

    1 point
  • Thomas Michael SemmlerThomas Michael Semmler, 9 months ago

    I'm not expecting anything from a company that has dribbble in their portfolio. They don't improve the site because they haven't found a way to monetize it more effectively.

    1 point