Designer News
Where the design community meets.
over 8 years ago from Cristian Moisei, http://meet-cristian.com
I think Photoshop seems to have found itself snowballed into its unfortunate position of accommodating to everything - yes i'll agree to that. But it's been a progressional thing - Photoshop has been around for a very long time, and a lot has changed throughout that time. Much like a web designer now needing to know how to code - compared to web designers back in the day.
Thats where tools like Sketch come in - they do a set range of things, and they do it to the best it can. (I say it like this, cause theres some bugs that bother crap out of me ha!)
Also another thing is that Photoshop is just another cog (albeit an important one) in the massive machine called Adobe. They have many, MANY users, applications, systems and internal politics (I'm sure they do, like any massive company). But what I'm trying to say is - quick and BIG changes like extracting a set of functions and putting them into a separate app is never going to happen quickly. However theres hope as they seem to picking up the ball game and becoming a bit more agile and focused.
Thats where tools like Sketch come in - they do a set range of things, and they do it to the best it can. (I say it like this, cause theres some bugs that bother crap out of me ha!)
Fireworks already did almost everything people praise Sketch for… yet Adobe decided it was better off killing that and rolling Sketch features into Photoshop rather than rebuilding their own slim MVP for screen design from the ashes of Fireworks.
THIS!!!
I seriously don't get why Adobe did this.
Fireworks could have been one of the best tools in the business if they had just put some effort into it.
I seriously don't get why Adobe did this.
Because they don't understand or even care about how their customers use their products.
Maybe because in their old business model, the more features they crammed in Photoshop, the more people would purchase new versions of it.
We can agree that using Photoshop for UI design 5 years ago was much less crazy than doing it today — and a leaner app like Fireworks perhaps wouldn't bring as much interest back then as it would today.
After they changed to Creative Cloud, it makes no fucking sense, though. I guess they are living with the consequences of their past decisions and now decided to just go with it.
I think I probably would disagree. At a certain level, and in certain industries, there is a high degree of bleed between different kinds of work - especially for video production or complex image manipulation. When Adobe dismantles products into multiple apps, some functionality tends to be duplicated across them, which then introduces its own set of issues (i.e., look at Premiere, After Effects, and Speedgrade, and the ways in which all three of these products can be used, in different ways, for colour grading, or the ways in which certain functionality ends up moving between Premiere and AE in subsequent generations).
The idea that applications are necessarily faster and more stable if their codebase is smaller isn't necessarily the case, especially if the alternative is moving files continuously across multiple separate applications, requiring intermediary tools (like Dynamic Link) to facilitate those transfers. Perhaps Sketch is a better tool for your workflow, and i think that's fine, but I'd imagine many PS users move across different kinds of functionality, and would much prefer to deal with a single interface for this instead of managing multiple smaller applications.
While having two discrete applications running might be worse in terms of performance, I would love to see a workflow between apps that allowed for files and data to be seamlessly exchanged between them — specially in a field like film editing/colouring/authoring.
If there's someone who could maybe pull this off, it would be Adobe, though I don't expect them to.
Designer News
Where the design community meets.
Designer News is a large, global community of people working or interested in design and technology.
Have feedback?
Photoshop trying to be everyone's everything is exactly the problem. Would you disagree that it would be better if PS's core functions would be split into separate apps? I don't do UI work, image manipulation, video work, 3d work and whatever other shit is crammed up under the same roof frequently enough to not afford being bothered to launch a separate, specialised app that I can trust will do the thing I need well.